Workplace Investigations · Approach
How I conduct investigations
Each investigation moves through the same five stages, from the conflict check to the written report.
Conflict check and engagement
I confirm that I have no relationship with the parties and agree on engagement terms with the employer or its counsel. At the outset, we decide whether the investigation should be privileged. That choice should be deliberate, never assumed.
Scope, in writing
The allegations are set out in writing before the first interview. If new information suggests the scope should change, I raise it with the employer rather than expanding or narrowing it myself.
Evidence and interviews
I identify the documents, messages and records to preserve. I then interview the complainant, the respondent and witnesses who can confirm or undermine a material allegation. Interviews take place by video (Zoom or Teams) or in person, with appropriate admonitions. Each party has a fair opportunity to respond to the allegations against them.
Analysis
I weigh the evidence on the preponderance standard, unless policy or a collective bargaining agreement requires another. Where the scope calls for it, I decide whether substantiated conduct violated a specific policy. I do not offer legal conclusions; those remain with the employer and its counsel.
The report
The report states the allegations, the evidence considered, the material conflicts and how I resolved them, and a reasoned finding on each allegation. It is written for the reader who will test it. Discipline and remedy remain the employer’s decision.
Why an attorney-conducted investigation
California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act regulations require impartial and timely investigations by qualified personnel. They do not say who must do the work, and an internal investigation is often the right choice. An outside attorney offers three things an internal team cannot:
- No structural conflict, where the investigator reports to or works alongside the person complained about.
- A deliberate choice, made at the outset, about whether to proceed under the attorney-client privilege (City of Petaluma v. Superior Court (2016) 248 Cal.App.4th 1023).
- A trained approach to scope, evidence, credibility and reasoning that will hold up when professionals examine it later.
An attorney performing an attorney’s duties is exempt from California’s Private Investigator Act licensing requirement (Bus. & Prof. Code § 7522(e)). The employer’s choice can therefore rest on qualifications and independence, not licensing.
Considering an outside investigation?
Send the names of the parties and a one-line description. I will confirm conflicts before any confidential detail is shared.